Through The Mayor's Eyes
The Only Complete History of the Mayor's of Buffalo, New York
Compiled by Michael Rizzo

BUFFALO'S
MAYORS
Mayors Home

1800-1832
1840's
1850's
1860's

1870's
1890's
1900-1910
1920 - 1930s
1940 - 1950s
1960 - 1970s
Cleveland Four
James Griffin
Anthony Masiello
Epilogue
Charts
Bibliography
Links
Index

Louis P. Fuhrmann

1910 - 1913, 1914-1917

HISTORY

                Louis P. Fuhrmann  was born in Buffalo , New York  on November 7, 1868. He lived at 288

Clinton Street on the city's East Side. He attended Public School No. 32 on Cedar Street and later attended Central High School Many members of the Fuhrmann family married into the local meat packing  families of the East Side. Fuhrmann's two sisters married members of the Klinck firm and his aunt married Jacob Dold , Sr.

                When Louis was attending Central High School he secured a part-time position with the C. Klinck Packing Co. started by Christian Klinck , working at their stall in the Elk Street Market. When Fuhrmann completed high school he was given a full-time job with the company.

                He gained thorough knowledge of the meat packing  industry and was offered an opportunity to work for the Jacob Dold  Packing  Company. In 1886 he moved to Kansas City, Kansas to take charge of their wholesale dressed beef business.

                Fuhrmann returned to Buffalo  in 1892 and started his own meat packing  business at 1010 Clinton  Street. The business became very profitable as the slaughterhouses and meat packing plants of Buffalo  prospered.

                In 1905 Fuhrmann was elected a member of the Board of Aldermen from the Fifth

ard, to serve for the following two years. In 1907 he was again elected a member of that same body by an even greater majority.

                "The Progressive" became his moniker as he worked for the rights of all the citizens.

                He was appointed acting mayor for four straight years under Mayor Adam It was during this time that his leadership qualities became well known to many citizens.

                The time the local candidates had for politicking was increasing with each campaign. In 1909 it was nearly a full month earlier than the previous campaign.

                The local conventions were held on Tuesday, September 14, 1909, giving the candidates nearly two months to campaign.

                The Republicans held their convention at the German-American Hall. They chose as their mayoral candidate, Jacob J. Siegrist, a well-known and successful merchant.

                The Democrats held their convention at Schwabl's Hall  and Fuhrmann was nominated while he was acting mayor; with Mayor Adam  currently on vacation in Scotland.

                Fuhrmann proved a surprise as the campaign took off into high gear. It was said that the race was won before his opponents woke up. The Democratic party  was split, many angered that Mayor Adam  was not re-nominated. If the Republicans had realized Fuhrmann's potential, they could have easily defeated him in this close run race.

                Fuhrmann's campaign pledges included improving the Buffalo  River, the passenger train terminal, the Hamburg turnpike and seawall, investigation of electric light and power, the University of Buffalo , the increasing of playgrounds, and the uniting of Buffalo  citizens.

 

LIFE AS A MAYOR

 

                Election day was November 2, 1909. The 6 p.m. edition of the Buffalo  Evening News headlines blared with the results of the election: "SIEGRIST THE NEXT MAYOR. Siegrist 29,274, Fuhrmann 28,310." By the time more  ballots were counted, though, the tide had turned. In their 'EXTRA' edition they declared Fuhrmann the victor. The following day's paper announced the final results, with Fuhrmann being elected by a small majority, 35,384 to 34,145, over his Republican counterpart, Councilman Jacob Siegrist

                A local Republican organ commented after the election:

                "One element in the canvass by Alderman Fuhrmann, which had much to do with winning him support, was the fact that he played the part of a gentlemanly and fair adversary, that in all his speeches, in the excitement of the campaign, he never referred to his political opponent...in any but the most kindly and cordial words. That is the sort of manliness, the kind of campaigning, which the voters of Buffalo  admire."

                It was a slim victory for Fuhrmann, as the Republicans stole the show, winning all the important offices in the city and county and nearly defeating Fuhrmann, but the citizens insisted on putting Fuhrmann into office.

                The Mayor-elect arrived at City Hall  early on January 1, 1910 for his inauguration. He was met by hundreds of friends and admirers waiting for his arrival. It was the first time in the history of Buffalo  mayoral inaugurations  that the room was lit by electricity. The Mayor's official home had been transformed from gas to electric.

                Mayor Fuhrmann  delivered some of the shortest annual messages ever presented to the Common Council Unlike his two predecessors, he usually just mentioned subjects that he felt needed immediate attention. His Inaugural Address  was delivered on January 1, 1910.

                "To the Honorable, the Common Council :

                "Gentlemen: Knowing most of you as I do, personally, and knowing further that you are practical men, I believe it unnecessary and unbecoming to address to you a dissertation upon your duties as public officials. We all agree that public business should be conducted upon the same principles and by the same methods as private business, though we find it difficult to put this theory into practice.

                "In the conduct of the business of our city I trust we shall at all times hew close to the line of common sense, keeping these thoughts in mind: the progress of our city and the prosperity and contentment of our people.

                "Buffalo  has already let the contract to develop a portion of Buffalo  River. I recommend to your Honorable Body that plans and specifications be prepared, bids asked for and contracts be let to complete the improvement of the river to the city line.

                "I recommend the immediate settlement on the best terms possible of the Sea Wall Strip and the Hamburg Turnpike matter, which settlement will permit us to develop our outer harbor. My judgment tells me that the future prosperity of Buffalo  depends largely on the commerce of our great lakes, a fact which the founders of our city had clearly in mind.

                "It is common knowledge that Buffalo  is suffering from inadequate terminal facilities. I feel certain that the railroads entering our city stand ready at present to give us relief. I also feel certain that the people of Buffalo  are prepared to meet the representatives of the railroads with that spirit of harmony and cooperation which must result in the settlement of this important question. I shall take up this matter with the railroads immediately and will make reports to your Honorable Body by special message.

                "Right or wrong, it is charged in many quarters that the use of electric power generated at Niagara Falls has been retarded in our city owing to the prices charged. An authoritative decision on this question can be made only by the Public Service Commission In justice to all parties concerned I shall ask for an immediate investigation of this subject by that body.

                "The project of a boulevard from Buffalo  to Niagara Falls has my support. I commend it to your Honorable Body for favorable consideration. Such a boulevard would indeed be a notable highway. To complete such a project requires the cooperation of the State and the cities and towns along the route. The advantages of it to our city from every point of view are so apparent that they require no discussion. I am informed that the city of Buffalo  is required to build only that three-quarters of a mile of road which is located within our city limits. The remainder is to be paid for by the State of New York and other cities concerned.

                "Now that a Greater Buffalo  University is to be realized, I recommend that your Honorable Body give to this popular educational enterprise such assistance as you in your judgment deem advisable. Personally, I want to go on record as being in hearty sympathy with this meritorious project.

                "I recommend that your Honorable Body continue the liberal policy which Buffalo  has heretofore manifested toward its public schools and public libraries. Buffalo  should go steadily forward in education matters.

                "I recommend to your Honorable Body that Buffalo 's splendid park system be maintained and expanded to meet the requirements of a growing, modern city. I also recommend careful and sympathetic consideration of the question of playgrounds for our children. This is an important subject.

                "I recommend to your Honorable Body that the streets of our city be maintained in the best possible condition. Necessary repairs must be promptly made.

                "I desire at this time to deal only with those urgent matters which command the unanimous support of our citizens. In my judgment the carrying out of these recommendations will begin the advancement of our city toward the goal desired by our people.

                Fuhrmann fully intended to live up to every campaign promise he made. Three months into his first term he was able to report progress on all his campaign pledges.

                Mayor Fuhrmann  delivered his second Annual Message to the Common Council  on January 3, 1911.

                "One of the greatest achievements of your honorable body was the adoption of a plan to improve Buffalo  River to the City Line. For thirty years citizens interested in the progress and development of Buffalo  have struggled conscientiously for this improvement.

                "The carrying out of this improvement means ten miles of additional commercial dockage to our city.

                "Another important matter was the taking by condemnation proceedings of the land lying between Georgia and Jersey Streets. I doubt if the people of our city realize the great value of water front property as an asset. This land lies close to our barge canal terminals, and our people have available three miles of dock frontage at this point.

                "The determination of your honorable body to use the Broadway Arsenal site for Convention Hall and exposition purposes is praiseworthy. The need of such a building is self-evident. Plans are complete and will shortly be advertised.

                "The selection of the Bennett Park site for a new Technical High School  is a satisfactory solution of a problem which has long been with us. The building of this school on this site, and the building of School 32, just across the street, with all the lands on Clinton Street between East Bennett and Cedar Streets added thereto for playground purposes, and with the completion of our Bennett Market, justifies the statement that this locality, on the completion of these improvements, will be one of the most attractive and interesting anywhere in our entire city.

                "The Ernest Wende Hospital for the Care of Contagious Diseases has been completely remodeled. I want the people of Buffalo  to know that there is nowhere in this country a better equipped hospital for the care of these diseases than this same Ernest Wende Hospital.

                "The Elmwood Avenue extension, now about half completed, in my judgment, is one of the most important improvements ever undertaken by our city. "The approval of your honorable body of the resolution requesting the Mayor, Comptroller and the Treasurer to certify the amount necessary...for park purposes, permitting the completion of our Park Zoo and the improvements at Cazenovia Park, is thoroughly commendable. The interest  shown in our present Zoo is proof of the educational value of a greater and up-to-date Zoo.

                "I have inspected the Police and Fire departments of our city and I am proud of both of them. No city has a finer body of men and no city has better equipment than ours. The deportment of the men in both departments is excellent.

                "During the past year a Playground Commission has been appointed. On the recommendation of this commission land was purchased for two new playgrounds, making altogether nine playgrounds at present under the control of the commission.

                "Your honorable body has before it the plans submitted by the Lackawanna Railroad , the Lehigh Valley Railroad  and the New York Central Railroad  for new passenger stations in our city. These propositions require immediate consideration.

                "The investigation into the prices charged by the Buffalo  General Electric Company and the Cataract Power and Conduit Company for electric light and power will begin as soon as my case is prepared. I have been working on this matter for months. I realize the importance of this investigation, and, naturally, I am anxious that our case shall not be defeated through any lack of preparation on my part.

                "In closing I wish to add a word concerning the future of our city. I am aware that many of our people, moved by a patriotic and civic spirit, are anxious to see Buffalo  move forward in the direction of more school houses, more hospitals, more parks, a new court house, a new market and kindred projects. Speaking for myself, I cheerfully concede that these institutions would enrich life in Buffalo , for, as a general proposition, the more our city can do in these regions the better off our people will be.

                "But the question that concerns me, as an executive, is 'Where is the money coming from to pay for these improvements!' As a practical man, I have learned that before our city can embark on all of these enterprises something must be done to substantially increase the assessable valuations and revenues of our city.

                "The settlement of these problems means the bringing to our city of new industries.

                "I mean to plant myself squarely on this subject, for I am positively convinced that it is my paramount duty to settle these questions."

                Mayor Fuhrmann  sent his third Annual Message to the Common Council  on January 1, 1912.

                "The year 1911 will be memorable for the settlement of the various great problems which have long confronted our city.

                "It is a matter of common knowledge that the Seawall and Hamburg Turnpike question has been settled.

                "Progress has been made in the settlement of the freight and passenger terminal situation by the sale of the Hamburg canal strip to the Lehigh Valley Railroad  company; said company having entered into an agreement, which agreement provides for the erection of a passenger station by that company...and the approval by the terminal commission of the Lackawanna proposition to erect a new passenger station at the foot of Main Street.

                "Agreements have been entered into between the City of Buffalo  and all the railroad companies, excepting the Lackawanna, for the placing of moveable bridges across the Buffalo  River.

                "I have filed a complaint with the Public Service Commission  asking for a reduction in the prices charged the people of our city for electric light and power. I assure the people of Buffalo  that nothing shall stop me from a vigorous prosecution of this all important and paramount question.

                "The city of Buffalo  has been liberal in the purchase of new playgrounds for our children. It is my judgment that before any more playgrounds are procured our present grounds should be adequately equipped.

                "I devoted a portion of my first annual message to the subject of a Niagara Falls boulevard It is in order to say that a portion of the Erie County part of the route, 2.92 miles, has been surveyed and bids advertised for leaving in Erie County un-contracted for at this date 2.84 miles. It is hoped and expected that the entire uncompleted portion of the route between Niagara Falls and Buffalo  will be contracted for this winter.

                "It seems in view of what is being done and the generous way in which the city of Niagara Falls has met the situation, that something ought to be done in Buffalo  to furnish a convenient and agreeable access to this boulevard from Buffalo There is a street now occupied by the street car tracks of the International Railway Company , running from Main Street to the junction of the town line road with Kenmore Avenue. this street...ought to be widened and paved so as to bring the boulevard traffic to Main Street.

                "I respectfully recommend that your honorable body give this Niagara Falls boulevard  project the consideration which it certainly deserves. In my judgment this enterprise should be pushed to a speedy conclusion.

                "So far in this communication I have referred only to those matters in which there has been substantial progress or actual settlement during the year 1911.

                "It would be easy for me, but unprofitable to anybody, to load down this communication with useless recommendations.

                "At this time it is enough to say that Buffalo  has its face set toward the future - that the people of our city are more alive than ever to their opportunities and their duties.

                "Throughout the city I find that our people are filled an ambition to get those things done which are in themselves worthwhile thinking less of the processes of their doing and more of the results to be accomplished."

                Mayor Fuhrmann , fully knowing it could be his last year in office, or possibly preparing for a re-nomination bid, delivered his longest annual address , to close out his first term on January 6, 1913. In it he covered more topics, in more detail, than he had previously before.

                "I congratulate you on the fact that the city of Buffalo  is enjoying a progress and a prosperity never before paralleled in its history. Every section of our city tells the same story - New office buildings, new business blocks, new manufacturing plants, new residences and new church edifices. Our people are universally optimistic and are enthusiastically working together on all questions relating to Buffalo 's future welfare I know that I am doing only justice when I state that the members of the Common Council  have done much to bring about this spirit of cooperation.

                "With work already begun by one railroad, namely the Lehigh Valley, leading to the actual realization of the long desired new terminal facilities, Buffalo  is now assured of the development of those natural resources which will increase our accessible values enormously and thereby bring a much needed revenue to our city.

                "The board of managers of the Public General Hospital  has engaged the architect to prepare plans for the hospital buildings to be erected on the West Farm site. Meanwhile, the Municipal Hospital on East Ferry Street, awaiting the final completion of the Public General Hospital, is being put into suitable condition for the care of advanced cases of tuberculosis  and it is expected will be ready to receive patients by March 1.

                "With the J. N. Adam Memorial  Hospital at Perrysburg adequately caring for incipient cases of tuberculosis  and with the provisions just mentioned for those in the advanced stages, the fact is clearly apparent that Buffalo  is performing its full duty in dealing with this dread scourge.

                "The Convention Hall on Broadway is nearly finished. The new Washington Market will be completed shortly.

                "Three years ago it was said, with righteous reproach of the city, that it owned no frontage on our magnificent harbor, outside of a few parcels on the inner harbor. Within this period there has been decided progress in actual acquisition or steps which it is expected will lead to actual possession within the coming year.

                "The tax rate in the minds of many is the paramount question in municipal affairs. The people should at all times watch closely the expenditures made by the city to the end that waste and extravagance shall not exist.

                "In concluding this annual message to your honorable body, I desire to thank you, each and all, for the courtesy which you have always displayed toward me in my official life.

                "During the year 1913 I believe we will best serve the interests of the city of Buffalo  by striving for the things which are necessary and attainable."

                The campaign of 1913 began in September. The Republican primary was held on September 16, and not a dissenting vote was cast for Thomas Stoddard  as he was unanimously chosen the Republican mayoral candidate. Two additional parties supplied nominees for the various elected offices, the Progressive and the Citizens party, but they both chose one mayoral candidate, John Lord O'Brian.

                The Democrats knew they needed a strong candidate to defeat the opposing nominations. The only choice appeared to be Mayor Fuhrmann At the primaries Fuhrmann was unanimously chosen for re-election. He accepted the re-nomination. It was declared that there would be no mud-slinging during the election as Stoddard and Fuhrmann were personal friends.

                Election day was November 4, 1913. Fuhrmann's popularity continued to grow as he easily defeated his two opponents by a larger majority than he did his first term. The combined split parties did more harm to themselves than to Fuhrmann. The Mayor received 30,219, Republican candidate Thomas Stoddard  received 13,447, and John Lord O'Brian received a combined 23,757; 13,203 from the Citizen's party and 10,554 from the Progressive party.

                It was a complete Democratic victory in the city and county as seven assemblymen, four councilmen, and a majority of the aldermen and supervisors were all elected.

                Mayor Fuhrmann  delivered his fifth consecutive, or Inaugural Address  of his second term, on January 5, 1914.

                "The most urgent problem confronting the city officials at this time is that of finance.

                "The constitution of the state provides that no city shall become indebted to an amount which shall exceed 10 per cent of the assessed valuation of the taxable real estate.

                "I am advised...[there is] a margin for the increase of our debt of approximately $6,000,000.

                "There are many large projects underway to which the city is committed which will require the issuance of bonds to a large amount to complete, which will very materially reduce the debt margin.

                "The increase in the bonded indebtedness during the past three years has been approximately $7,500,000 - an amount greater by approximately $1,000,000 than our present debt margin.

                "The foregoing figures are impressive as indicating first, that great care should be exercised in committing ourselves to undertakings demanding increases in our funded debt, and second, that some method should be devised of enlarging our debt margin so as to provide for projects which are essential to the growth and well-being of our city.

                "The tax rate of the city for 1913  was approximately $22.50 per thousand dollars of valuation.

                "I can see little hope of reducing the tax rate. I desire to point out this situation at this time in order that you may be fully advised of the necessity of a policy of retrenchment and economy in the administration of the city's affairs.

                "...A large portion of our financial budget is a fixed and permanent charge, yet I am persuaded that there is otherwise room for retrenchment and economy.

                "It seems to be generally admitted that our present school accommodations are inadequate.

                "...More important than high school facilities is sufficient grammar school accommodations and in this respect we seem to be woefully inadequate. This is a subject of just importance to the welfare  of the city and all other projects involving the city should be subordinated to this one.

                "The way should be made easy for every child to obtain a common school education and we must immediately address ourselves to removing the reproach that our city, by inadequate common schools  accommodations, is depriving children of opportunities for education.

                "The Turnpike and Sea Wall agreements with the railroads, already an accomplished fact, have paved the way for the development of the outer harbor. We should reasonably expect that in a short time that harbor will be

developed so as to become a greater center of commercial activity.

                "As you are well aware, the City and County Hall  is inadequate to furnish accommodations for the city and county offices and as a result, many offices...are located in private buildings, thereby burdening the city and the county with a large rent charge.

                "It is my judgment that the city should [forego] interest in the present City and County Hall  to the county and that the city should undertake the erection of a municipal building of a modern type on the land owned by the city where the department of public works is now located.

                "Under the present system for the collection of taxes , the taxpayer is required to pay in advance, under heavy penalty for non-payment, his entire tax for the fiscal year.

                "...I believe that by making it easier to pay the tax the city would gain materially in reducing the number of tax delinquents.

                "The docks of the city are largely owned and controlled by private interests, corporate and otherwise. Many of them are in a dilapidated condition and very few of them are creditable to a harbor the size and importance of ours.

                "There may be some question under our present charter as to whether the city has sufficient control of private docks and wharves to enforce the erection and maintenance of suitable docks. The private interests in control of these docks have shown no particular disposition toward their improvement and I think the time has come when the city should be vested with such power.

                "There are numerous things properly within the field of municipal endeavor which will be submitted during the term of your Honorable Body, and I can assure you of my cooperation in any measures by Your Honorable Body which will make for a better and greater Buffalo "

                The year 1914 provided many changes to the city and to the world. In July, World War I  began as Austria declared war on Serbia. At the polls in November, 1914, in addition to voting for various offices, the citizens of Buffalo  were to cast their ballots for a change in the organization of the city government. A commission form of government had become popular in many American cities and the people wanted to try it here. It proposed a commission consisting of five members, including the mayor, completely eliminating the entire Common Council There were many people on both sides of the battle. Mayor Fuhrmann  did not believe this was a logical choice for Buffalo , and many citizens agreed with him.

                Unfortunately, many more sided with the Charter Campaign Committee. On November 3, 1914 the commission charter was chosen by the voters, 36,362 to 20,891, with over 18,000 blank votes. The citizens fighting against the charter were disappointed. "...A commission charter is not suited to a city the size of Buffalo ," stated Charles L. Feldman , chairman of the Citizens' Union. Mayor Fuhrmann  stated, "I have no statement to make. It was a Republican landslide and the charter went with it." John P. Sullivan , President of the Board of Aldermen: "The people have spoken and I have no complaint to make. Meanwhile, the ice business is excellent," obviously in reference to his personal business.

                District Attorney Martin P. Devlin of Trenton, New Jersey, who was one of the principal speakers for the charter during the campaign, wired his congratulations election night: "Congratulations for Buffalo  on more government by the people."

                The new charter would not go in effect until January 1, 1916. Under the terms of the charter, the Mayor could complete his current term and is elected for four years with his salary set at $8,000 per year. He would preside at all meetings of the council and has a vote, but no veto power. Each councilman is also elected for a four year term.

                In November 1915 four councilmen would be elected, the one receiving the least number of votes would serve for two years, to coincide with the completion of the mayor's term, the other three would each begin four-year terms.

                The city's business was now divided between this five-member commission. There were five departments:

Public Safety - including fire, police , and health; Finance and Accounts - including comptroller, treasurer, auditor, and assessors; Public Affairs - including educational, and poor departments; Public Works - including bureau of water, streets, building, and engineering; and Parks and Public Buildings. The mayor is automatically assigned the head of the Public Safety department, and a majority vote is needed to fill each of the other four departments.

                Probably the biggest change in government, and the reason it was overwhelmingly favored, was that the people were given veto power through The Referendum. Any ordinances or money-spending resolutions passed by the council, except for emergencies, could not take effect for thirty days. If five percent of the voters signed a petition against the ordinance, the council had to reconsider the action or submit it to a special election.

                In addition to that, the primaries and general elections were to be non-partisan. All voters could vote at the primary, regardless of party affiliation. The city primary was three weeks before the election, and any citizen could run for the office of mayor or councilman if he filed a petition with 300 signatures on it. The two mayoral candidates with the highest number of votes were the nominees. For councilmen, twice as many are nominated than are required to fill the offices, again by the largest number of votes. This was done to create a nonpartisan government, and there was to be no political line-ups or organizing by one party in this new commission.

                At the general election all winners for mayor or councilman were chosen by the greatest number of votes.

                Mayor Fuhrmann  delivered his sixth consecutive annual address , second of this term, to the Common Council  on January 4, 1915.

                "The people at the recent election decreed a radical change in the form of administering our municipal affairs, which becomes effective a year hence.

                "It is interesting to recall in this connection that the new form of government is practically a revision to the type of city government contained in the charter of 1832 creating our city. In that original charter a council of 10, elected by wards, was given complete legislative and administrative power and the appointment of substantially all of the executive officers.

                "Practically like powers are given the council of five under the commission charter.

                "In the course of time the original form of our city government was deemed unsuited for the proper administration of a great and growing city and the existing form of our municipal government was evolved. It is perhaps true that our present system goes too far in making the legislative body cumbersome and permitting it to interfere with the work of the administrative officers and in dividing up administrative responsibility among a large number of elective officers. I felt, as did many other good citizens, that these defects could be corrected without vesting the whole power of government in a council of five.

                "However, the people have spoken, and although we may differ as to the wisdom of the radical change, it is our duty to conduct our affairs during the present year so as to not embarrass, but, on the contrary, so as to facilitate the transition from the old to the new on January 1, 1916.

                "A survey of the constructive work done for our city during the recent years indicates that most of the large undertakings deemed essential to the growth and prosperity of the city have been done or are rapidly nearing completion and have already been financed by the city. Among these great undertakings may be mentioned:

                "Elimination of Grade Crossings.

                "Buffalo 's River Improvement.

                "Seawall and Hamburg Turnpike.

                "The rights of the city and of the railroad companies along the outer harbor have been definitely fixed by contract.

                "The Water System.

                "Within a few months it is expected that the new pumping station, providing a new source of supply of water. ...We have a system adequate for the city's use for the next half century or more.

                "School Facilities.

                "Three new high schools have been opened within the past year, namely, Hutchinson, Masten Park , and Technical, and the South Side High School will open for the reception of pupils next fall.

                "A considerable expenditure has been incurred in the past few years in the acquirement of property for parks and playgrounds, and the only criticism I have heard in that respect is that we have gone too fast in this direction.

                "I have enumerated these large constructive undertakings of recent years simply for the purpose of showing

that our public officials have been active in the forwarding improvements vital to the growth of the city and elementally necessary to its development.

                "In conclusion, permit me to say that the best evidence that our city affairs have been upon the whole well managed is that our financial stand has been maintained even during the recent financial stress. We may congratulate ourselves also that, notwithstanding the general depression in business throughout the country, Buffalo  has not seriously suffered, but our business men and financial institutions have passed through this period of stress with very little trouble. I bespeak your cordial cooperation in our tasks during the present year and I ask it with confidence because of your generous cooperation in the past."

                On January 1, 1916, the new form of government was ushered in dawning a new era for the city of Buffalo The first week of the commission charter proved to be quite interesting.

                On January 3, 1916 the first formal meeting of the new commission took place. Mayor Fuhrmann  serves as chairman of the board, and the councilmen chosen at the November election were: Charles B. Hill , Arthur W. Kreinheder , Charles M. Heald , and John F. Malone

                During the first meeting Heald resigned, unhappy that he was not given the head of department of public works as was previously decided between the members. He was then informed that he could not just resign, and he received hundreds of calls from citizens urging him not to. Therefore, he reconsidered and appeared at the next meeting of the council.

                At the January 5, 1916 meeting of the commission, the election of the department heads was completed. Kreinheder , who had decided he wanted the department of public works, was elected head of that department, even though Mayor Fuhrmann  voted against it; Hill was elected to head of finances; Heald in charge of public affairs; and Malone to head parks and buildings.

                People in Buffalo